How do you compare car finance properly?
Compare like with like. Fix the loan amount and the term first, then put every offer next to each other on total repayable, fees, balloon, security and early-payout rules. If two quotes differ on any of those, the repayment alone can’t tell you which is better.
That sounds obvious, but most comparisons online rank products by a single headline number. The car you drive home from the yard is paid for over years, so the structure around that number matters as much as the number itself.
Moneysmart’s car loan guidance says the same thing in its own way: compare the features, the fees and the cost, and use the comparison rate only for loans of the same amount and term. Our car loans page shows how the main structures fit together. If you’d rather have the lining-up done for you, tell us about the car and we’ll bring back options to compare.
Which seven things should you line up side by side?
Seven features change what a car loan costs or how flexible it is: term, total repayable, fees, balloon, security, early payout and extra repayments. Write them in one table for each quote and the difference between offers shows up quickly.
| Check | Why it matters | Ask this |
|---|---|---|
| Loan term | Longer means lower repayments but a bigger total | How many months, and what’s the total repayable? |
| Fees | Upfront and ongoing charges are added to the cost | What are the establishment and monthly fees, and is anything else charged? |
| Balloon | A lump sum due at the end lowers repayments now | How much is it, and what’s my plan for it? |
| Security | Most car loans are secured over the vehicle | Is the car the security, and does it meet your age limits? |
| Early payout | Selling or refinancing early can trigger charges | What does it cost to close the loan in year two? |
| Extra repayments | Paying more can shorten the loan | Can I pay extra without a penalty? |
| Repayment flexibility | Life changes over a five-year term | What happens if I need to pause or restructure? |
The first two do most of the heavy lifting. Take a $35,000 loan as a simple example: stretching it over seven years rather than five brings each repayment down, yet the extra two years of payments and fees usually leave you paying more in total. Your own figures will differ, which is why the loan repayment calculator is worth running on two or three term lengths.
Why does the balloon change the comparison?
A balloon is a lump sum you owe at the end of the loan. It lowers each repayment because you’re not paying that slice off along the way, but you still owe it, and it usually adds to what you pay overall. Compare balloon offers by the balloon amount as well as the repayment.
Two quotes can show the same weekly figure with very different endings: one fully paid off, one with a large amount still due. If you’re weighing it up, our balloon payments guide explains how to plan for it.
Treat the balloon as a decision about the future. Will you keep the car, sell it, or trade it in? Because cars lose value quickly, a big balloon on a car you plan to sell early can leave you with a gap between the sale price and the payout.
- Keeping the car long term: a smaller balloon, or none, keeps the end of the loan simple.
- Planning to trade up in a few years: a balloon can suit, as long as you’ve checked likely resale value.
- Unsure either way: compare a no-balloon quote alongside it before you decide.
Is dealer finance different from a broker car loan?
Yes. Dealer finance is arranged at the point of sale, usually with a lender or lenders the dealer works with. A broker searches a panel of lenders for your situation. Both can be fine, and both are worth putting next to each other, because the setup behind a loan can affect what you’re charged.
ASIC’s June 2026 review of car loans, Report 832, looked at more than 350,000 loans from eight providers. It found that loans typically carried two establishment fees, one to the lender and one to the distributor who sold the loan, and that some lenders had weak oversight of the brokers and dealers selling their products. As ASIC put it, “responsibility for consumer outcomes cannot be outsourced.”
The practical lesson is to ask for every fee in writing and to ask who is being paid for the loan. It’s a fair question to put to a dealer, a broker or us, and a good answer should be short and clear.
| Dealer finance | Broker finance | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it happens | At the dealership, with the car in front of you | Before or alongside the car search |
| Choice of lenders | Often the dealer’s own arrangements | A panel, so more structures to compare |
| Timing pressure | Can feel like a ‘sign today’ moment | You can line up finance before you shop |
| What to ask | Every fee, add-ons, and who is paid | The same questions, plus which lenders were searched |
One more tip: dealers often offer add-ons such as extended warranties or insurance at the desk. Ask whether each one is optional and whether it’s being rolled into the loan, since that adds interest to something you might have declined if it were priced separately.
Does new, used or private-sale change the comparison?
Yes, because lenders set limits by the age and type of car, and those limits shape the term, security and structure you can get. A new car usually opens up the widest choice, while an older or private-sale car narrows it, so compare offers that were actually built for the car you’re buying.
For a new car, balloons and longer terms are often on the table, which is where our new car finance page helps. For a used car, lenders look closely at age and kilometres, and the used car finance page explains how that plays out.
Buying privately adds one more step. Search the car’s VIN on the Personal Property Securities Register to check for finance owing before any money moves, and use our private sale car checklist as your guide.
If you’re also weighing a novated lease, the novated lease vs car loan guide sets out how the structures differ so you’re comparing the right things.
How do you get a car loan comparison without applying everywhere?
Go through someone who searches for you. Each formal application can leave an enquiry on your credit file, so applying to several lenders yourself to ‘see who says yes’ is the slow and messy way. A broker compares a panel for you from one enquiry, and enquiring with us will not affect your credit score.
Checking your own credit report doesn’t affect it either, and you can get a free copy from the credit reporting bodies, as Moneysmart explains. Knowing what’s on the file before you compare is a smart first move.
Fancy seeing what your options could look like? Tell us about the car and what you’d like the repayments to feel like. The form takes about 2 minutes, a lender only runs a credit check once you choose to apply, and we tell you before that happens.
A real person in our team reads your details, searches a panel of 60+ lenders, and talks you through the choices start to finish. Please fill the form in accurately so we can match the right loan first time.
What you’ll need
- Driver licence and a second form of ID
- Recent payslips, or tax returns if you’re self-employed
- Recent bank statements
- The car’s year, make, model, kilometres and VIN, or the dealer quote
- Any quotes you’ve already been given, with the fees listed
- A list of your current debts and regular expenses
- Details of any deposit or trade-in
Who it usually suits
- Aged 18 or over
- Australian citizen or permanent resident (some lenders consider visa holders)
- Regular income that comfortably covers the repayments
- A car that meets the lender’s age and type limits if you want it secured
- A credit history lenders can assess; less-than-perfect credit is looked at case by case